Как установить биекцию между деревом и его обходом?

Ответ 1

Вы были на правильном пути с вашей леммой listSplit. Вы можете использовать эту функцию, чтобы узнать, находится ли целевой элемент в левой или правой части дерева.

Это соответствующая строка из моей реализации

inTreeThenInorder x (branch y l r) e with listSplit x (inOrder l) (y ∷ inOrder r) e

Здесь полная реализация. Я включил его как внешнюю ссылку, чтобы избежать нежелательных спойлеров, а также воспользоваться преимуществами гиперссылки с гиперссылкой, выделяемой синтаксисом Agda.

http://www.galois.com/~emertens/agda-tree-inorder-elem/TreeElem.html

Ответ 2

Я написал inorderToFro и inorderFroTo и связанные леммы в Идрисе. Здесь ссылка.

Есть несколько моментов, которые я могу сделать о вашем решении (не вдаваясь в подробности):

Во-первых, splitMiddle не требуется. Если для splitRight используется более общий тип Right p = listSplit xs ys loc -> elemAppend xs ys p = loc, то он может покрывать одно и то же основание.

Во-вторых, вы можете использовать больше шаблонов with вместо явных _lem функций; Я думаю, что это было бы более ясным и более кратким.

В-третьих, вы выполняете значительную работу, доказывая splitLeft и co. Часто имеет смысл перемещать свойства функции внутри функции. Итак, вместо того, чтобы писать listSplit и доказательства его результата отдельно, мы можем изменить listSplit, чтобы вернуть необходимые доказательства. Это часто проще реализовать. В моем решении я использовал следующие типы:

data SplitRes : (x : a) -> (xs, ys : List a) -> (e : Elem x (xs ++ ys)) -> Type where
  SLeft  : (e' : Elem x xs) -> e' ++^ ys = e -> SplitRes x xs ys e
  SRight : (e' : Elem x ys) -> xs ^++ e' = e -> SplitRes x xs ys e

listSplit : (xs, ys : List a) -> (e : Elem x (xs ++ ys)) -> SplitRes x xs ys e

Я мог бы также использовать Either (e' : Elem x xs ** (e' ++^ ys = e)) (e' : Elem x ys ** (xs ^++ e' = e)) вместо SplitRes. Однако я столкнулся с проблемами с Either. Мне кажется, что унификация высшего порядка в Идрисе слишком шатко; Я не мог понять, почему моя функция unsplitLeft не проверила typecheck с Either. SplitRes не содержит функций в своем типе, поэтому я думаю, что он работает более плавно.

В общем, в это время я рекомендую Агда над Идрисом написать такие доказательства. Он проверяет намного быстрее, и он намного более прочен и удобен. Я очень удивлен, что вам удалось написать так много Идриса здесь и другого вопроса об обходах деревьев.

Ответ 3

Мне удалось выяснить, как доказать, что можно перейти от местоположения дерева к месту списка и вернуться от чтения типов лемм, на которые ссылается glguy answer. В конце концов, мне тоже удалось пойти другим путем, хотя код (ниже) довольно ужасен. К счастью, я смог повторно использовать лексики ужасающего списка, чтобы доказать соответствующую теорему об обходах предзаказов.

module PreIn
import Data.List
%default total

data Tree : Type -> Type where
  Tip : Tree a
  Node : (l : Tree a) -> (v : a) -> (r : Tree a) -> Tree a
%name Tree t, u

data InTree : a -> Tree a -> Type where
  AtRoot : x `InTree` (Node l x r)
  OnLeft : x `InTree` l -> x `InTree` (Node l v r)
  OnRight : x `InTree` r -> x `InTree` (Node l v r)

onLeftInjective : OnLeft p = OnLeft q -> p = q
onLeftInjective Refl = Refl

onRightInjective : OnRight p = OnRight q -> p = q
onRightInjective Refl = Refl

noDups : Tree a -> Type
noDups t = (x : a) -> (here, there : x `InTree` t) -> here = there

noDupsList : List a -> Type
noDupsList xs = (x : a) -> (here, there : x `Elem` xs) -> here = there

inorder : Tree a -> List a
inorder Tip = []
inorder (Node l v r) = inorder l ++ [v] ++ inorder r

rotateInorder : (ll : Tree a) ->
                (vl : a) ->
                (rl : Tree a) ->
                (v : a) ->
                (r : Tree a) ->
                inorder (Node (Node ll vl rl) v r) = inorder (Node ll vl (Node rl v r))
rotateInorder ll vl rl v r =
   rewrite appendAssociative (vl :: inorder rl) [v] (inorder r)
   in rewrite sym $ appendAssociative (inorder rl) [v] (inorder r)
   in rewrite appendAssociative (inorder ll) (vl :: inorder rl) (v :: inorder r)
   in Refl


instance Uninhabited (Here = There y) where
  uninhabited Refl impossible

instance Uninhabited (x `InTree` Tip) where
  uninhabited AtRoot impossible

elemAppend : {x : a} -> (ys,xs : List a) -> x `Elem` xs -> x `Elem` (ys ++ xs)
elemAppend [] xs xInxs = xInxs
elemAppend (y :: ys) xs xInxs = There (elemAppend ys xs xInxs)

appendElem : {x : a} -> (xs,ys : List a) -> x `Elem` xs -> x `Elem` (xs ++ ys)
appendElem (x :: zs) ys Here = Here
appendElem (y :: zs) ys (There pr) = There (appendElem zs ys pr)

tThenInorder : {x : a} -> (t : Tree a) -> x `InTree` t -> x `Elem` inorder t
tThenInorder (Node l x r) AtRoot = elemAppend _ _ Here
tThenInorder (Node l v r) (OnLeft pr) = appendElem _ _ (tThenInorder _ pr)
tThenInorder (Node l v r) (OnRight pr) = elemAppend _ _ (There (tThenInorder _ pr))

listSplit_lem : (x,z : a) -> (xs,ys:List a) -> Either (x `Elem` xs) (x `Elem` ys)
  -> Either (x `Elem` (z :: xs)) (x `Elem` ys)
listSplit_lem x z xs ys (Left prf) = Left (There prf)
listSplit_lem x z xs ys (Right prf) = Right prf


listSplit : {x : a} -> (xs,ys : List a) -> x `Elem` (xs ++ ys) -> Either (x `Elem` xs) (x `Elem` ys)
listSplit [] ys xelem = Right xelem
listSplit (z :: xs) ys Here = Left Here
listSplit {x} (z :: xs) ys (There pr) = listSplit_lem x z xs ys (listSplit xs ys pr)

mutual
  inorderThenT : {x : a} -> (t : Tree a) -> x `Elem` inorder t -> InTree x t
  inorderThenT Tip xInL = absurd xInL
  inorderThenT {x} (Node l v r) xInL = inorderThenT_lem x l v r xInL (listSplit (inorder l) (v :: inorder r) xInL)

  inorderThenT_lem : (x : a) ->
                     (l : Tree a) -> (v : a) -> (r : Tree a) ->
                     x `Elem` inorder (Node l v r) ->
                     Either (x `Elem` inorder l) (x `Elem` (v :: inorder r)) ->
                     InTree x (Node l v r)
  inorderThenT_lem x l v r xInL (Left locl) = OnLeft (inorderThenT l locl)
  inorderThenT_lem x l x r xInL (Right Here) = AtRoot
  inorderThenT_lem x l v r xInL (Right (There locr)) = OnRight (inorderThenT r locr)

unsplitRight : {x : a} -> (e : x `Elem` ys) -> listSplit xs ys (elemAppend xs ys e) = Right e
unsplitRight {xs = []} e = Refl
unsplitRight {xs = (x :: xs)} e = rewrite unsplitRight {xs} e in Refl

unsplitLeft : {x : a} -> (e : x `Elem` xs) -> listSplit xs ys (appendElem xs ys e) = Left e
unsplitLeft {xs = []} Here impossible
unsplitLeft {xs = (x :: xs)} Here = Refl
unsplitLeft {xs = (x :: xs)} {ys} (There pr) =
  rewrite unsplitLeft {xs} {ys} pr in Refl

splitLeft_lem1 : (Left (There w) = listSplit_lem x y xs ys (listSplit xs ys z)) ->
                 (Left w = listSplit xs ys z) 

splitLeft_lem1 {w} {xs} {ys} {z} prf with (listSplit xs ys z)
  splitLeft_lem1 {w}  Refl | (Left w) = Refl
  splitLeft_lem1 {w}  Refl | (Right s) impossible

splitLeft_lem2 : Left Here = listSplit_lem x x xs ys (listSplit xs ys z) -> Void
splitLeft_lem2 {x} {xs} {ys} {z} prf with (listSplit xs ys z)
  splitLeft_lem2 {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {z = z} Refl | (Left y) impossible
  splitLeft_lem2 {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {z = z} Refl | (Right y) impossible

splitLeft : {x : a} -> (xs,ys : List a) ->
            (loc : x `Elem` (xs ++ ys)) ->
            Left e = listSplit {x} xs ys loc ->
            appendElem {x} xs ys e = loc
splitLeft {e} [] ys loc prf = absurd e
splitLeft (x :: xs) ys Here prf = rewrite leftInjective prf in Refl
splitLeft {e = Here} (x :: xs) ys (There z) prf = absurd (splitLeft_lem2 prf)
splitLeft {e = (There w)} (y :: xs) ys (There z) prf =
  cong $ splitLeft xs ys z (splitLeft_lem1 prf)

splitMiddle_lem3 : Right Here = listSplit_lem y x xs (y :: ys) (listSplit xs (y :: ys) z) ->
                   Right Here = listSplit xs (y :: ys) z

splitMiddle_lem3 {y} {x} {xs} {ys} {z} prf with (listSplit xs (y :: ys) z)
  splitMiddle_lem3 {y = y} {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {z = z} Refl | (Left w) impossible
  splitMiddle_lem3 {y = y} {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {z = z} prf | (Right w) =
    cong $ rightInjective prf  -- This funny dance strips the Rights off and then puts them
                               -- back on so as to change type.


splitMiddle_lem2 : Right Here = listSplit xs (y :: ys) pl ->
                   elemAppend xs (y :: ys) Here = pl

splitMiddle_lem2 {xs} {y} {ys} {pl} prf with (listSplit xs (y :: ys) pl) proof prpr
  splitMiddle_lem2 {xs = xs} {y = y} {ys = ys} {pl = pl} Refl | (Left loc) impossible
  splitMiddle_lem2 {xs = []} {y = y} {ys = ys} {pl = pl} Refl | (Right Here) = rightInjective prpr
  splitMiddle_lem2 {xs = (x :: xs)} {y = x} {ys = ys} {pl = Here} prf | (Right Here) = (\Refl impossible) prpr
  splitMiddle_lem2 {xs = (x :: xs)} {y = y} {ys = ys} {pl = (There z)} prf | (Right Here) =
    cong $ splitMiddle_lem2 {xs} {y} {ys} {pl = z} (splitMiddle_lem3 prpr)

splitMiddle_lem1 : Right Here = listSplit_lem y x xs (y :: ys) (listSplit xs (y :: ys) pl) ->
                   elemAppend xs (y :: ys) Here = pl

splitMiddle_lem1 {y} {x} {xs} {ys} {pl} prf with (listSplit xs (y :: ys) pl) proof prpr
  splitMiddle_lem1 {y = y} {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {pl = pl} Refl | (Left z) impossible
  splitMiddle_lem1 {y = y} {x = x} {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {pl = pl} Refl | (Right Here) = splitMiddle_lem2 prpr

splitMiddle : Right Here = listSplit xs (y::ys) loc ->
              elemAppend xs (y::ys) Here = loc

splitMiddle {xs = []} prf = rightInjective prf
splitMiddle {xs = (x :: xs)} {loc = Here} Refl impossible
splitMiddle {xs = (x :: xs)} {loc = (There y)} prf = cong $ splitMiddle_lem1 prf

splitRight_lem1 : Right (There pl) = listSplit (q :: xs) (y :: ys) (There z) ->
                  Right (There pl) = listSplit xs (y :: ys) z

splitRight_lem1 {xs} {ys} {y} {z} prf with (listSplit xs (y :: ys) z)
  splitRight_lem1 {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {y = y} {z = z} Refl | (Left x) impossible
  splitRight_lem1 {xs = xs} {ys = ys} {y = y} {z = z} prf | (Right x) =
    cong $ rightInjective prf  -- Type dance: take the Right off and put it back on.

splitRight : Right (There pl) = listSplit xs (y :: ys) loc ->
             elemAppend xs (y :: ys) (There pl) = loc
splitRight {pl = pl} {xs = []} {y = y} {ys = ys} {loc = loc} prf = rightInjective prf
splitRight {pl = pl} {xs = (x :: xs)} {y = y} {ys = ys} {loc = Here} Refl impossible
splitRight {pl = pl} {xs = (x :: xs)} {y = y} {ys = ys} {loc = (There z)} prf =
  let rec = splitRight {pl} {xs} {y} {ys} {loc = z} in cong $ rec (splitRight_lem1 prf)


---------------------------
-- tThenInorder is a bijection from ways to find a particular element in a tree
-- and ways to find that element in its inorder traversal. `inorderToFro`
-- and `inorderFroTo` together demonstrate this by showing that `inorderThenT` is
-- its inverse.

||| `tThenInorder t` is a retraction of `inorderThenT t`
inorderFroTo : {x : a} -> (t : Tree a) -> (loc : x `Elem` inorder t) -> tThenInorder t (inorderThenT t loc) = loc
inorderFroTo Tip loc = absurd loc
inorderFroTo (Node l v r) loc with (listSplit (inorder l) (v :: inorder r) loc) proof prf
  inorderFroTo (Node l v r) loc | (Left here) =
    rewrite inorderFroTo l here in splitLeft _ _ loc prf
  inorderFroTo (Node l v r) loc | (Right Here) = splitMiddle prf
  inorderFroTo (Node l v r) loc | (Right (There x)) =
    rewrite inorderFroTo r x in splitRight prf

||| `inorderThenT t` is a retraction of `tThenInorder t`
inorderToFro : {x : a} -> (t : Tree a) -> (loc : x `InTree` t) -> inorderThenT t (tThenInorder t loc) = loc
inorderToFro (Node l v r) (OnLeft xInL) =
  rewrite unsplitLeft {ys = v :: inorder r} (tThenInorder l xInL)
  in cong $ inorderToFro _ xInL
inorderToFro (Node l x r) AtRoot =
  rewrite unsplitRight {x} {xs = inorder l} {ys = x :: inorder r} (tThenInorder (Node Tip x r) AtRoot)
  in Refl
inorderToFro {x} (Node l v r) (OnRight xInR) =
  rewrite unsplitRight {x} {xs = inorder l} {ys = v :: inorder r} (tThenInorder (Node Tip v r) (OnRight xInR))
  in cong $ inorderToFro _ xInR